Blog

Derivative Misconduct - What Does It Mean?

Derivative Misconduct - What Does It Mean?

AF Consulting

Derivative Misconduct - What does it mean?

In a recent document published by SA Labour Guide, it was pointed out that a ruling by the Constitutional Court places a restriction of the use of “derivative misconduct” to dismiss employees. In short, derivative misconduct is a form of misconduct where an employee fails to offer reasonable assistance in the detection and identification of those employees who are responsible for some sort of misconduct.  It means that employees who are aware of misconduct, but choose to remain silent, may be guilty of a derivative violation of the trust relationship.    

According to the document written by James Horn and Neil Coetzer from Cowan - Harper - Madikizela Attorneys, the ruling states that derivative misconduct can only be used as a last resort for employers who are victims of collective misconduct.

They suggest that the application of derivative misconduct can only be used in respect of employees who do not have a fiduciary relationship with their employers. In other words, ordinary employees who have no fiduciary duty do not have to disclose to their employers any knowledge of misconduct.

What does this mean for the employer?

“While the Constitutional Court has not ruled out derivative misconduct as a form of misconduct altogether, it has nevertheless substantially limited its application in respect of employees who do not hold fiduciary relationships to their employers (i.e. directors/prescribed officers)”.

It was suggested that employers would have to be more watchful during strikes to monitor and identify culprits of misconduct themselves.  Employers may have to consider using cameras to assist them with this task.  It is also vital for employers to keep detailed records of the strike.

Should you need assistance with any labour-related matters, please feel free to contact AF Consulting today. 

Derivative Misconduct - What Does It Mean?

AF Consulting

AF Consulting in Hermanus specialises in Labour Law Compliances, Human Resources Management and General Bookkeeping. General Administration for businesses as well as Personal General Administration are services also offered by Arina Fyfer who strives to be your personal HR assistant. Arina is availa...

View Profile

What is Xplorio?

Xplorio is your local connection allowing you to find anything and everything about a town.

WATCH THE VIDEO: Welcome to Hermanus
Read More

Recent Posts

Half Day Vacancy Hermanus: Medical Receptionist

Half Day Vacancy Hermanus: Medical Receptioni...

My client is looking to employ a half-day reception and admin assistant.

AF Consulting
Need Help With Employment Equity Reporting?

Need Help With Employment Equity Reporting?

The annual reporting period begins on 1 September and closes on 15 January each year.

AF Consulting
Vacancy Hermanus - Cost and Management Accountant

Vacancy Hermanus - Cost and Management Accoun...

My client is a growing company in the production field supplying local and international markets.

AF Consulting
Part-time Vacancy Hermanus - Admin Assistant

Part-time Vacancy Hermanus - Admin Assistant

My client needs some help in the office with someone who can keep up to date with accounts and general running of the business. 

AF Consulting
Vacancy Hermanus -Technician / Driver

Vacancy Hermanus -Technician / Driver

We are looking for someone who is a responsible driver, who is also a problem solver with excellent client skills.

AF Consulting
Vacancy Hermanus: Service Administrator

Vacancy Hermanus: Service Administrator

My client is looking for the ideal candidate to join their already successful team. Closing: 1 September.

AF Consulting