Blog

Derivative Misconduct - What Does It Mean?

Derivative Misconduct - What Does It Mean?

AF Consulting

Derivative Misconduct - What does it mean?

In a recent document published by SA Labour Guide, it was pointed out that a ruling by the Constitutional Court places a restriction of the use of “derivative misconduct” to dismiss employees. In short, derivative misconduct is a form of misconduct where an employee fails to offer reasonable assistance in the detection and identification of those employees who are responsible for some sort of misconduct.  It means that employees who are aware of misconduct, but choose to remain silent, may be guilty of a derivative violation of the trust relationship.    

According to the document written by James Horn and Neil Coetzer from Cowan - Harper - Madikizela Attorneys, the ruling states that derivative misconduct can only be used as a last resort for employers who are victims of collective misconduct.

They suggest that the application of derivative misconduct can only be used in respect of employees who do not have a fiduciary relationship with their employers. In other words, ordinary employees who have no fiduciary duty do not have to disclose to their employers any knowledge of misconduct.

What does this mean for the employer?

“While the Constitutional Court has not ruled out derivative misconduct as a form of misconduct altogether, it has nevertheless substantially limited its application in respect of employees who do not hold fiduciary relationships to their employers (i.e. directors/prescribed officers)”.

It was suggested that employers would have to be more watchful during strikes to monitor and identify culprits of misconduct themselves.  Employers may have to consider using cameras to assist them with this task.  It is also vital for employers to keep detailed records of the strike.

Should you need assistance with any labour-related matters, please feel free to contact AF Consulting today. 

Derivative Misconduct - What Does It Mean?

AF Consulting

AF Consulting in Hermanus specialises in human resources, recruitment, labour relations and training in the workplace. Human Resources Consultant, Arina Fyfer, is available to personally assist you in a focused recruitment process when hiring employees. AF Consulting’s HR service packages are tail...

View Profile

What is Xplorio?

Xplorio is your local connection allowing you to find anything and everything about a town.

WATCH THE VIDEO: Welcome to Hermanus
Read More

Recent Posts

Skilled Waiters Available for Hire in Hermanus

Skilled Waiters Available for Hire in Hermanu...

Looking for skilled waiter staff?

AF Consulting
How to Support Dyslexia in the Workplace: Tips and Tools

How to Support Dyslexia in the Workplace: Tip...

Let's talk about dyslexia in the workplace. 

AF Consulting
How to Promote Positivity in Your Business This October

How to Promote Positivity in Your Business Th...

October is Positive Attitude Month, and as a business owner, maintaining a positive mindset is essential.

AF Consulting
Top Companies Prioritising Emotional Wellness at Work

Top Companies Prioritising Emotional Wellness...

Emotional wellness is not just a personal journey - it’s vital to a thriving workplace culture.

AF Consulting
Mastering Progressive Discipline in South African Labour Law

Mastering Progressive Discipline in South Afr...

It’s surprising how many don’t know that South African Labour Law prioritizes correcting behaviour over immediately resorting to dismissal.

AF Consulting
Policies, Procedures and Fair Treatment

Policies, Procedures and Fair Treatment

It's heartbreaking to see stories of employees being mistreated.

AF Consulting